The challenge
Michael and Sarah were expecting their third child in a house that had already run out of room. He is an electrician running his own business, she manages administration, and between them they earn around $210,000. They had $520,000 left on a Sydney home worth about $1,150,000, which put roughly $630,000 of equity behind them. On the face of it, upgrading to a $1,350,000 family home was well within reach.
The equity was never the problem. How a lender would read Michael's income was.
Ledgersmith had been doing the accounting for the business for years, and it had been structured properly to manage tax, which is exactly what a good accountant is paid to do. But the figure a lender uses to test whether you can afford a loan comes out of those same financials. Manage taxable income down and, without anyone intending it, you can manage borrowing capacity down with it. The two goals pull against each other, and most self employed borrowers only discover it after they have found the house, made an offer and lodged the application, which is the worst possible moment to find out.
What we did
Because the accounting already sat in the same building, we could start work on the loan before there was a loan to apply for. We put them in front of Loren Marsh, our own mortgage broker, and the two sides worked the problem together.
- Mapped the position in full: about $1,150,000 of property against $520,000 of debt, roughly $630,000 of gross equity before selling costs
- Calculated the exact income Michael would need to demonstrate to satisfy the lender's servicing test on a $1,350,000 purchase, so there was a target to plan towards rather than a hope to test
- Took that target straight to the people already holding the financials, so nothing had to be requested, chased or explained from scratch
- Worked through the business financials together, so Michael's returns presented the genuine earning capacity of the business while the tax position stayed properly managed. Nobody paid a dollar of extra tax simply to qualify for a loan
- Compared lenders on self employed policy specifically, because lenders differ widely on how they treat business income, what they will add back and how much trading history they require. For a self employed borrower, that single choice can change a borrowing capacity dramatically
- Answered the lender's questions on the business financials as they arose, from the people who had prepared them, rather than letting the file stall
- Coordinated the sale, the purchase, the lender and the conveyancer through to settlement
Why your accountant and your broker should talk
A broker working alone has to ask for financials, wait for them, then interpret figures they had no hand in preparing. If something in those figures is going to cause trouble with a lender, it tends to surface late, once the offer is already in and there is no time left to do anything about it. That is when self employed buyers get told no.
Here the two sides were the same firm. The people who prepared the financials and the broker who had to put them to a lender were talking months before an application existed, which is the only point at which the answer could still be changed. Most brokers cannot offer that, through no fault of their own. They simply never see the tax side of the picture.
The results
They sold for around $1,150,000, cleared the $520,000 mortgage, and put part of the proceeds towards the deposit and purchasing costs on the new home. The new loan came to approximately $850,000 against a $1,350,000 purchase, a loan to value ratio of about 63%, comfortably under the 80 per cent threshold, so no Lender's Mortgage Insurance was payable.
The family got the extra bedrooms and the backyard before the third child arrived, and Michael kept a tax position he could live with.
If you are self employed, the lesson is that it is worth talking early. The room to plan sits in the year before you buy, not the week before, and it is far easier when the people doing your books and the people arranging your loan work together.


