The challenge
Barry and Betty did not come to us about their mortgage. They came to us for their tax.
He is an engineer, she teaches, and between them they earn around $180,000. Ledgersmith had been handling their accounting for years, which means that once a year we see the whole picture: what they earn, what they owe and what it is costing them. Sitting in that picture was a $650,000 home loan against a Sydney property now worth $950,000, at 6.2 per cent variable.
That rate was the problem, and they had no particular reason to know it. Their bank was advertising sharper deals to people walking through the door for the first time, and paying nothing to keep the customers already on its books. The industry has a name for it, the loyalty tax. Nobody writes to tell you it is happening. We only noticed because we were already looking at their numbers, and we raised it with them rather than waiting to be asked.
They also wanted to renovate. Roughly $100,000 of work, funded from the equity they had already built. What they did not know was how much they could actually borrow, whether releasing that equity would tip them into Lender's Mortgage Insurance, or how to compare a dozen offers with different rates, fees and exit costs and tell which one was genuinely better.
What we did
We put them in front of Loren Marsh, our own mortgage broker, who started with the financial picture already in hand rather than a blank form. Then:
- Compared offers across the lender panel and found a 5.89 per cent variable rate with a new lender
- Went back to their existing bank, which came up to 6 per cent, still behind the market
- Found a competing lender offering $2,000 cashback, more than enough to cover the cost of moving
- Released the $100,000 for renovations while keeping total lending at $750,000 against a $950,000 valuation, a loan to value ratio just under 80 per cent, so no Lender's Mortgage Insurance was payable
- Split the loan so it worked both ways: $550,000 fixed at 5.4 per cent for three years for certainty, $200,000 variable at 5.89 per cent so they can make extra repayments whenever they want
- Folded a $15,000 credit card balance into the new structure at home loan rates rather than card rates
- Ran the $350 exit fee and the $500 in new lender set up costs through the numbers before recommending anything, so the saving was proven rather than assumed
- Handled the paperwork and had the loan approved in three weeks
Why your accountant and your broker should talk
Most people keep the two apart without ever deciding to. The accountant sees the full financial position once a year and has no reason to look at the loan. The broker sees the loan, and has to ask for the financials, wait for them, then work with whatever arrives. Neither is doing anything wrong. But nobody is joining the two together, and a loan quietly running above the market can sit there for years while everyone assumes somebody else is watching it.
At Ledgersmith the two sit in the same business. The people preparing the tax return and the broker arranging the loan can simply walk down the hall, and that is exactly what happened here. A broker working on their own cannot offer that, however good they are, for the simple reason that they never see the tax side of your position at all.
The results
The lower rate saves them $2,015 a year in interest. The $2,000 cashback covered the $850 of switching costs several times over. The renovation is funded, without a dollar of Lender's Mortgage Insurance, and the credit card debt now sits inside the mortgage at a fraction of the rate it was costing them.
Their old bank was never going to volunteer the better rate. It only moved when somebody asked on their behalf, and even then it did not move far enough. Barry and Betty were never going to go looking either, and they did not have to. The people already doing their books were the ones who noticed.


